I’ve been watching some rather entertaining toing and froing between a few blog sites, most notably Hard unTruth and Pharyngula. Sadly entertainment value has dropped to zero with the formers refusal to actually check their ‘facts’ and the latter’s (or rather the reader’s of the latter) refusal to realise that Tom Estes is willfully ignorant and unwilling to examine things logically.
Of course as someone pointed out T. Estes looks distinctly like a joke name, suggesting that the site may in fact be a parody sight designed to highlight the deplorable lack of education and critical thinking within the public. Sadly if this is the case it may well be backfiring as the informed are getting tied up arguing against a satirte site and the uninformed think it is championing their blind ignorance.
The cherry on top is of course the sheer tunnel vision of the site. The ‘pastor’ is a creationist defender, in his opinion Creationism is correct and backs this opinion by taking examples form the 1 scientist in every 20,000 that has apparently found some inconsistency in fossil records or carbon dating, or simply disagrees with old fashioned, evidence backed, science. Of course if you happen to disagree with his world view because you are not a believer in a higher power, or don’t have a patriarchal and monotheistic religious structure, or one that doesn’t descend from the Jeudo-Christian tradition, that didn’t break away from Catholicism centuries ago, and that didn’t splinter from a specific Christian faction decades ago that Tom shares, and you don’t believe in creationism, then you’re wrong.
Tom just doesn’t get it.
Faith asks “why?”. Science asks “how?”.
Not all scientists are atheists.
Not all atheists care about science.
You can still learn the How of evolution, astro-physics, geology, and cellular biology without even touching on the Why. Similarly you can submerge yourself in theology of the Why and never bother with the How. Sadly a uneducated pastor from location X can not stop himself from spouting that his interpretation of the Why trumps all the millions of studies, fossil records, ice core samples and evidence of How, despite the fact he hasn’t bothered to check his facts.
A man has a holy book his God handed down to him as being the Truth. This could be said of the Bible, the Torah, the Koran, the Vedas, the Book of Mormon and a thousand others. Apparently his Truth trumps the other Truths because…… errr… actually he doesn’t tell us why, just as he doesn’t show us any science to claim that science backs up the bible.
Sorry Tom, if you’re not intentionally running a parody site then you’re unintentionally running one. Its sick humor however, depressing, ignorant, and pedagogically flawed. It saddens me to think that our greatest gifts of awareness and curiosity are being curtailed in the pursuit of faith, especially when so many have proven that the two are not incompatible.